"gpt 6.2 astra vs fable 5.2" appeared in Google autocomplete within 24 hours of the GPT-6.2 launch — search demand for this comparison formed on day one. The answer is clean: Astra trails by 3 points on the AA index (62 vs 65), costs about 6.6× less per task ($4.00 vs $26.54), and leads on AA-3D. This article settles the account with independent measurements and labels OpenAI's self-reported lead separately.
| Dimension | GPT-6.2 Astra | Claude Fable 5.2 |
|---|---|---|
| AA Intelligence Index v5.0.1 | 62 (Max, top 3 of 91) | 65 (Max, No. 1 of 74) |
| Price (input / output) | $8 / $40 | $8 / $40 (identical) |
| Cost per index task | $4.00 | $26.54 (6.6× Astra) |
| Time per task | 11.5 min | About 45.3 min |
| Tokens per task | 65.8M | — |
| AA-3D Elo | 1,318 (No. 1) | 1,271 |
| AA-AnalystAgent | 62.5% | — |
| Context | 1.05M tokens | 1M tokens |
| Max output | 128K tokens | 128K tokens |
| Knowledge cutoff | May 18, 2026 | June 2026 |
| Weights | Closed | Closed |
The most striking row is the price: the two models share the same list price ($8/$40), yet per-task costs differ by 6.6×. The gap is task time (11.5 vs 45.3 minutes) and token usage, not the rate card. Fable Max thinks longer and runs longer, so its bill is higher.
The AA Intelligence Index composites 9 evaluations. Fable leads by 3 points, but Astra reverses it on AA-3D (1,318 vs 1,271), so the gap is not across the board. Fable's edge sits in long-horizon agents and scientific reasoning (see our Fable topic, section 06C); Astra's edge is in blind-rated 3D generation and cost efficiency. Three index points in exchange for a 6.6× bill gap — that is the core trade-off of this comparison.
OpenAI's own claim puts Astra 5.5 points ahead of Fable 5.2 on Agents' Last Exam at 5% of the cost (Fable about $60 per task, per aiweekly); the AA X post gives Astra about 78% at about $3 per task. Both figures come from OpenAI's side or AA's single post, and Fable's score is OpenAI's own re-run rather than Anthropic's published value — no independent reproduction yet. Cite it as "vendor-reported"; never write it into a table of independent measurements.
Pick Astra when the budget is tight, task volume is high, you want the No. 1 blind-rated 3D score, or tasks should finish in the 11.5-minute range. Astra is one of the cheapest flagships per task near the top of the board. Pick Fable for the hardest long-horizon agent, science and research work, with a budget that tolerates $26.54 per task — or when you need independent backing Astra doesn't have yet, such as the Vals Index at 71.31% and LiveBench 2.0 at 84.9%. Pick neither: for everyday work, look at Sol first — OpenAI's own claim puts Sol within 0.5 points of Astra on FrontierCode at a quarter of the price.
Reference: Artificial Analysis — GPT-6.2 Astra model page · Artificial Analysis — Claude Fable 5.2 model page (rewritten and organized by ModelBrief; facts per official sources and Artificial Analysis)