Claude Haiku 5.5 is the rival Meta names in its launch post, and the benchmark eesel.ai invokes when it calls Ember "the cheapest way to get Claude Haiku 5.5-level results". The comparison has a rare shape: identical list prices, identical AA Index scores, and a threefold gap in cost per task. This article takes it apart in four layers — price, index, component benchmarks and ecosystem — then ends with a decision checklist.
List prices: both $0.10 in / $0.50 out per 1M tokens. Cached input: Ember $0.004, ~60% cheaper than Haiku's ~$0.01. Cost per task (AA Index): Ember $0.14, Haiku $0.41. The gap comes from usage: on the AA Index Ember used ~115M output tokens against Haiku's ~298M. The conclusion is clean: Ember is not cheaper per token — it completes the same tasks with fewer tokens. But there is an asymmetry: Ember has a 200K price cliff (whole requests at 3× above it), and Haiku has no such line — on over-long-context work, Ember's price advantage gets eaten by the cliff.
AA Intelligence Index v5.0 (max effort): both score 36. Spark 1.3 (max) scores 37, one point higher. A tied index means comparable general intelligence — but the index is a composite, and the components tell a finer story. One more AA component: Omniscience, where Ember scores 21.1%, the lowest among models with similar overall scores; Haiku's Omniscience was not confirmed in this round and is left blank.
Six component benchmarks (all Meta-reported, reproducing AA evaluations; rival scores as Meta lists them): AutomationBench-AA 37.8% vs 13.9% (Ember scores nearly 2.7× Haiku — the widest gap); Terminal-Bench 4.0 40.9% vs 39.2% (a win by just 1.7 points); FrontierCode 2.0-AA 27.2% vs 34.9% (Ember loses by 7.7 points); OSWorld 2.1 69.5% vs 68.9% (a win by just 0.6 points); Agents' Last Exam 61.6 vs 57.0; PerceptionBench 80.6 vs 78.6. Ember wins five and loses one — but two of the wins are under 2 points, and the loss is 7.7 points. Business workflows are Ember's biggest win; coding is its biggest loss.
Ember's main doors are Muse Code (all plans) and the Meta Model API, plus Google Cloud, Oracle Cloud and the Vercel AI Gateway; Haiku 5.5's main doors are Claude Code and the Anthropic API. Neither has open weights. Ember's context is 1M tokens with 512K max output; Haiku 5.5's context was not confirmed in this round and is left blank. Reasoning tiers: Ember has six (minimal to max, default max), with Meta publishing max-effort results only; Haiku 5.5's tier structure was not confirmed in this round. The biggest ecosystem difference is the division of labour: Meta pushes a two-model pattern — "Wonder plans, Ember executes" — while Haiku more often carries lightweight work alone inside Anthropic's lineup.
| Task type | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| High-volume repeatable execution: sub-agents, tool calls, routing, extraction | Ember | Same index, a third of the cost per task; the big AutomationBench win |
| Business-process automation | Ember | AutomationBench-AA 37.8% vs 13.9% |
| Code-heavy work | Haiku 5.5 | FrontierCode 27.2% vs 34.9% — Ember loses by 7.7 points |
| Long-context work over 200K input | Do the math first | Ember bills the whole request at 3× above 200K; Haiku has no such cliff |
| Terminal and computer-use tasks | Ember (narrowly) | TB 4.0 wins by just 1.7 points, OSWorld by just 0.6 — a small edge |
| Budget-sensitive work at volume | Ember | $0.14 per task vs $0.41; cache ~60% cheaper |
In one line: the more repeatable, the less code-dependent and the further from the 200K line a task is, the better Ember looks; the heavier the code and the longer the context, the safer Haiku is.
On the AA Intelligence Index v5.0 (max effort) both score 36 — a tie. But the components differ: Ember leads on five boards including AutomationBench, trails on FrontierCode, and its AA-Omniscience 21.1% is the lowest in its class. "Equally smart" holds only at the composite-index level.
Per task, yes ($0.14 vs $0.41); per token, no — the list prices are identical. The saving comes from Ember using fewer output tokens. But mind the 200K cliff: requests over 200K input bill the whole request at 3×, and Haiku has no such line.
Haiku 5.5. On FrontierCode 2.0-AA it scores 34.9% against Ember's 27.2% — Ember's clearest loss of the six boards; and the AA Coding Agent Index of 46 is Meta's figure, not independent evidence of Ember's coding ability.
Neither. Ember is API-only — Meta's open-weight Muse model is Glimmer / Spark Open; Haiku 5.5 likewise ships no open weights.
Reference: Artificial Analysis — Index 36, cost per task $0.14 / $0.41 · Meta research blog — six component benchmarks, two-tier pricing · eesel.ai ("the cheapest way to get Claude Haiku 5.5-level results") · agentfred.ai (output-token usage ~115M vs ~298M) (rewritten and organized by ModelBrief; facts per the AA evaluation and the Meta launch post)