ModelBrief · Muse Ember · Topic Page
Last updated Nov 20, 2026

Muse Ember vs Claude Haiku 5.5: Same Price, Same Index, a Third of the Cost

ModelBrief · Published 2026-11-16 · Fact-check 2026-11-16 · Reference: Artificial Analysis, Meta research blog

Claude Haiku 5.5 is the rival Meta names in its launch post, and the benchmark eesel.ai invokes when it calls Ember "the cheapest way to get Claude Haiku 5.5-level results". The comparison has a rare shape: identical list prices, identical AA Index scores, and a threefold gap in cost per task. This article takes it apart in four layers — price, index, component benchmarks and ecosystem — then ends with a decision checklist.

Layer one: price — same rates, a third of the cost per task

List prices: both $0.10 in / $0.50 out per 1M tokens. Cached input: Ember $0.004, ~60% cheaper than Haiku's ~$0.01. Cost per task (AA Index): Ember $0.14, Haiku $0.41. The gap comes from usage: on the AA Index Ember used ~115M output tokens against Haiku's ~298M. The conclusion is clean: Ember is not cheaper per token — it completes the same tasks with fewer tokens. But there is an asymmetry: Ember has a 200K price cliff (whole requests at 3× above it), and Haiku has no such line — on over-long-context work, Ember's price advantage gets eaten by the cliff.

Layer two: the index — 36 vs 36, a tie

AA Intelligence Index v5.0 (max effort): both score 36. Spark 1.3 (max) scores 37, one point higher. A tied index means comparable general intelligence — but the index is a composite, and the components tell a finer story. One more AA component: Omniscience, where Ember scores 21.1%, the lowest among models with similar overall scores; Haiku's Omniscience was not confirmed in this round and is left blank.

Layer three: component benchmarks — five wins, one loss

Six component benchmarks (all Meta-reported, reproducing AA evaluations; rival scores as Meta lists them): AutomationBench-AA 37.8% vs 13.9% (Ember scores nearly 2.7× Haiku — the widest gap); Terminal-Bench 4.0 40.9% vs 39.2% (a win by just 1.7 points); FrontierCode 2.0-AA 27.2% vs 34.9% (Ember loses by 7.7 points); OSWorld 2.1 69.5% vs 68.9% (a win by just 0.6 points); Agents' Last Exam 61.6 vs 57.0; PerceptionBench 80.6 vs 78.6. Ember wins five and loses one — but two of the wins are under 2 points, and the loss is 7.7 points. Business workflows are Ember's biggest win; coding is its biggest loss.

Muse Ember vs Claude Haiku 5.5 component benchmarks (Meta-reported) Muse Ember Claude Haiku 5.5 AutomationBench-AA 37.8% 13.9% Terminal-Bench 4.0 40.9% 39.2% FrontierCode 2.0-AA 27.2% 34.9% OSWorld 2.1 69.5% 68.9% Agents' Last Exam 61.6 57.0 PerceptionBench 80.6 78.6
Six component benchmarks (%; Meta research blog, Nov 9, 2026; all vendor-reported, reproducing AA evaluations; orange is Muse Ember, grey is Claude Haiku 5.5)

Layer four: ecosystem and use — Muse Code vs Claude Code

Ember's main doors are Muse Code (all plans) and the Meta Model API, plus Google Cloud, Oracle Cloud and the Vercel AI Gateway; Haiku 5.5's main doors are Claude Code and the Anthropic API. Neither has open weights. Ember's context is 1M tokens with 512K max output; Haiku 5.5's context was not confirmed in this round and is left blank. Reasoning tiers: Ember has six (minimal to max, default max), with Meta publishing max-effort results only; Haiku 5.5's tier structure was not confirmed in this round. The biggest ecosystem difference is the division of labour: Meta pushes a two-model pattern — "Wonder plans, Ember executes" — while Haiku more often carries lightweight work alone inside Anthropic's lineup.

The decision checklist: which one to pick

Task typePickWhy
High-volume repeatable execution: sub-agents, tool calls, routing, extractionEmberSame index, a third of the cost per task; the big AutomationBench win
Business-process automationEmberAutomationBench-AA 37.8% vs 13.9%
Code-heavy workHaiku 5.5FrontierCode 27.2% vs 34.9% — Ember loses by 7.7 points
Long-context work over 200K inputDo the math firstEmber bills the whole request at 3× above 200K; Haiku has no such cliff
Terminal and computer-use tasksEmber (narrowly)TB 4.0 wins by just 1.7 points, OSWorld by just 0.6 — a small edge
Budget-sensitive work at volumeEmber$0.14 per task vs $0.41; cache ~60% cheaper

In one line: the more repeatable, the less code-dependent and the further from the 200K line a task is, the better Ember looks; the heavier the code and the longer the context, the safer Haiku is.

FAQ

Which is smarter, Ember or Haiku 5.5?

On the AA Intelligence Index v5.0 (max effort) both score 36 — a tie. But the components differ: Ember leads on five boards including AutomationBench, trails on FrontierCode, and its AA-Omniscience 21.1% is the lowest in its class. "Equally smart" holds only at the composite-index level.

Is Ember really a third of Haiku 5.5's cost?

Per task, yes ($0.14 vs $0.41); per token, no — the list prices are identical. The saving comes from Ember using fewer output tokens. But mind the 200K cliff: requests over 200K input bill the whole request at 3×, and Haiku has no such line.

Which one for code-heavy work?

Haiku 5.5. On FrontierCode 2.0-AA it scores 34.9% against Ember's 27.2% — Ember's clearest loss of the six boards; and the AA Coding Agent Index of 46 is Meta's figure, not independent evidence of Ember's coding ability.

Do either have open weights?

Neither. Ember is API-only — Meta's open-weight Muse model is Glimmer / Spark Open; Haiku 5.5 likewise ships no open weights.

ModelBrief's take: Ember vs Haiku is a "same price, different fate" comparison: identical index, identical rates, with the outcome decided by token usage and the component boards. Ember's value story is real, but its boundaries are equally clear — coding and the 200K cliff. Calling Ember a "cheap Haiku" is wrong; calling it "a Haiku substitute for repeatable execution work, except code" is right.

Reference: Artificial Analysis — Index 36, cost per task $0.14 / $0.41 · Meta research blog — six component benchmarks, two-tier pricing · eesel.ai ("the cheapest way to get Claude Haiku 5.5-level results") · agentfred.ai (output-token usage ~115M vs ~298M) (rewritten and organized by ModelBrief; facts per the AA evaluation and the Meta launch post)